Exura Global

Comparison

Copy trading vs PAMM vs MAM

Copy trading, PAMM and MAM all let investors follow a trader, but they differ in who controls the account and where the money sits. In copy trading each follower keeps an account and chooses settings. In PAMM capital is pooled in one managed account. In MAM a manager trades many segregated accounts with one order.

Updated

Copy trading vs PAMM vs MAM

Copy trading vs PAMM vs MAM
FeatureCopy tradingPAMMMAM
Who controls the accountThe follower. The follower subscribes, sets capital, multiplier and stop loss, and can stop copying at any time.The manager. The manager trades the pooled account; investors decide only when to deposit or withdraw.The manager trades a master account. Each investor account receives allocated trades under a mandate.
Ownership of fundsEach follower's funds stay in the follower's own trading account.Investors own a percentage share of one pooled account.Each investor keeps a separate account in their own name; capital is not pooled.
Trade allocationEach trade is replicated in proportion to the follower's equity and chosen multiplier or fixed lot.Trades are not allocated: one account trades and results are distributed by share.One order on the master is split across sub-accounts: proportional, equal, multiplier or custom.
Typical feesPerformance fee to the strategy provider; sometimes subscription, management or volume fees.Performance fee and management fee per period, distributed automatically.Performance and management fees per account, agreed with the manager.
Transparency for the investorHigh: public statistics per strategy and every copied trade visible in the follower's account.Medium: share value, statements and period results; individual trades are not controlled by the investor.High at account level: each investor sees their own account, trades and statement.
Typical regulatory pointsMay be treated as portfolio management or investment advice depending on the set-up; check locally.Pooling client money is sensitive and may require specific authorisation; check locally.Usually a discretionary mandate, which often requires a portfolio management or similar licence.
Ideal audienceRetail clients who want to choose and change strategies themselves.Investors who want a fully delegated, pooled product with one share price.Professional managers and funds that run separate investor accounts with one order.
How a broker offers itA copy module connected to the trading server, with provider and follower portals in the traders' room.A PAMM module that manages shares, deposits, withdrawals, fees and statements on the platform.A MAM engine connected to the server, with master account, allocation rules and per-investor reporting.

Three models, one goal

Copy trading, PAMM and MAM are the three common ways for a broker to let clients invest through another trader. All three turn passive clients into active accounts and create volume without the client making every decision. The difference lies in three questions: who decides each trade, where the money is held and how results reach each investor.

In copy trading, the strategy provider trades a normal account and publishes it as a strategy. Followers subscribe from their own accounts and the copy engine replicates each trade, scaled to the follower's equity and settings. The follower can change the multiplier, set a stop loss or unsubscribe at any time, so control stays with the follower.

In a PAMM, investors transfer capital into one account that the manager trades. Every deposit and withdrawal recalculates each investor's percentage, and profits, losses and fees are distributed per period. Investors hold a share, not a separate trading account, and they do not intervene in individual trades.

In a MAM, each investor keeps a separate account in their own name, and the manager trades a master account. The allocation engine splits every order across the investor accounts according to a chosen method. Capital is never pooled, but decisions are delegated to the manager.

How trades are allocated and how fees work

Allocation is the technical core of each model. In copy trading the engine reads the provider's trade and calculates the follower's volume. A common approach scales by equity ratio: if the follower's equity is a quarter of the provider's, the copied trade is a quarter of the size. cTrader Copy, for example, describes an equity-to-equity ratio for this calculation. Other engines let the follower choose a fixed lot or a multiplier. Rounding to the broker's minimum lot and handling of closed markets or insufficient margin must be defined.

A PAMM avoids allocation because there is only one trading account. The work moves to accounting: each investor's share is recalculated at every deposit or withdrawal, and fees are calculated per period on the pool's result. The timing of the calculation, the rollover period and the treatment of open positions during deposits must be clear to investors.

A MAM allocates each master order to sub-accounts. Typical methods are proportional to equity or balance, equal lots per account, a fixed multiplier per account and custom percentages. Each sub-account then has its own positions, margin and statement, which makes reconciliation per investor straightforward.

Fees follow the same logic in all three. The usual pay structure for the trader is a performance fee on new profits, measured against a high-water mark so investors do not pay twice for recovering losses. Some providers add a management fee on equity, a subscription fee or a volume-based fee. The broker earns from spreads and commissions on the copied or allocated volume, and sometimes from a share of the fees.

  • Copy trading: proportional to equity, fixed lot or multiplier, chosen by the follower.
  • PAMM: no allocation; results distributed by percentage share.
  • MAM: proportional, equal, multiplier or custom, chosen by the manager.

Regulatory points to check before launching

How regulators classify these services depends on the jurisdiction and on the exact set-up, so each broker must confirm the position with its own regulator and counsel. As a reference, in March 2023 the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) published a supervisory briefing on copy trading under MiFID II.

The briefing explains that when orders based on a copied trader are executed automatically, without the client acting before each trade, the service is likely to be portfolio management, which requires the corresponding authorisation. When the client must act before each transaction, other services such as investment advice or reception and transmission of orders may apply instead. ESMA also sets expectations on information to clients, costs and charges, product governance, inducements and the selection of the traders who are copied.

PAMM and MAM raise similar questions. A manager who trades investor accounts under a discretionary mandate usually needs a licence that covers portfolio management, and pooling client money in one account is treated with particular care by many regulators. The broker that hosts the product must decide which entity holds the mandate, how investor funds are protected and which clients can access it.

How a broker implements each model

All three models need software connected to the trading server, a front end for investors and managers, and links to the CRM for accounts, deposits and reports. On MetaTrader 5, these modules run alongside the server and read trades in real time. MT5 also includes its own Signals service on the MQL5 community, which lets subscribers copy providers' trades; a broker-run copy module differs because the broker controls the brand, the rules and the fees.

For copy trading, the broker needs provider and follower portals, public statistics, risk controls per subscription and automated fee settlement. For PAMM, it needs share accounting, deposit and withdrawal windows, fee calculation and statements per investor. For MAM, it needs a master account, an allocation engine with several methods and per-account reporting.

Operations matter as much as features. The broker must decide who can become a provider or manager, what track record is required, how risk warnings are shown and how complaints are handled. Support teams need to understand how a copied trade, a PAMM share or a MAM allocation was calculated when a client asks.

Exura Copy offers copy trading, MAM and PAMM under the broker's brand, connected to MT5 and integrated with Exura Core or with its own panel. USD 2,000/month for PAMM, MAM or Social Trading individually, or USD 3,000/month for all three. Each plan includes 1,000 accounts; additional accounts cost USD 0.50 each per month.

When to choose each option

  • Copy trading

    Choose copy trading when your clients are retail traders who want to pick and switch strategies themselves, keep their own account and control their risk per subscription.

  • PAMM

    Choose PAMM when investors want a fully delegated, pooled product with one result per period, and your licence and processes cover pooled client money.

  • MAM

    Choose MAM when professional managers or funds need to trade many segregated investor accounts with one order and report per investor.

Frequently asked questions

Copy trading lets each follower replicate a strategy in their own account with their own settings. PAMM pools investor capital in one account traded by a manager. MAM lets a manager trade many separate investor accounts from one master account.

Sources

  1. ESMA — Supervisory briefing on copy trading (ESMA35-42-1428) · esma.europa.eu · accessed October 31, 2026
  2. ESMA — ESMA provides guidance for supervision of copy trading services · esma.europa.eu · accessed October 31, 2026
  3. cTrader Help Centre — cTrader Copy · help.ctrader.com · accessed October 31, 2026
  4. MQL5 — Trading signals for MetaTrader · mql5.com · accessed October 31, 2026

This comparison is general information for businesses and is not legal, regulatory or investment advice. Copy trading, MAM and PAMM are operated by the broker under its own licence and obligations. Copying a strategy does not guarantee results; past performance does not predict future results.

Talk to the team behind these guides

Tell us where your brokerage is today and we will walk you through liquidity, technology and payments for your case.

Contact sales